Background on the Theme

For additional background on the IARSLCE conference theme, Connected Knowing, read our first post from KerryAnn O'Meara, the 2012 conference program chair

Monday, March 12, 2012

Harry Boyte, Center for Democracy and Citizenship, Augsburg College



Harry C. Boyte, Director of the Center for Democracy and Citizenship, Augsburg College
Senior Fellow, Humphrey School of Public Affairs


Connected Knowing and the Politics of Civic Agency

Some years ago (2000) I wrote an essay for a special issue of the journal of the American Association of University Professors, Academe. The issue was called “Are We Good Citizens? – Civic Engagement and Higher Education,” and my article was entitled “The Struggle Against Positivism.” For those interested, it is on the web. I was pleased with the venue – the distinguished journal of the association and at places trade union of faulty. And I was glad to see another sign of the awakening interest in citizenship which it represented.

But I was discomfited with the subtitle given my essay – “Academics can be public intellectuals but they can’t pose as ‘experts.’” This struck me as far too dismissive of the disciplines and knowledge assiduously acquired by academics. The concept of “craft” is, in my view, a much better concept than “expert,” but the subtitle seemed, wrongly, to obliterate the skills, habits, and knowledge acquired in disciplinary study. This is a significant, if common mistake in the engagement movement. I was especially dismayed at the picture on the cover. An older academic, beaming, was surrounded by adoring African American children, several of whom were hugging him.  In this ensemble of images and themes can be found both the strength and the limit of the dominant approaches in the public or civic engagement movement in recent years. These can also be implicit in “connected knowing.” 

The dominant approach to public engagement grows from the communitarian philosophical framework, energized by the strong impulses of many in higher education to break out of the cultures of isolation, detachment, and individualism which have grown up over the last half century. This detachment is the product of a default positivism woven into our institutions. Positivism is based on a particular politics of knowledge, which holds that detached and “objective” scholars are the singular font of sound knowledge. The human costs of such detachment are severe. When Ed Fogelman, chairman of the Department of Political Science and I did interviews with senior academic leaders at the University of Minnesota, across many disciplines, in 1997-98, we heard again and again the human costs of “success” in such a culture: feelings of isolation, dispiritedness, loss of larger public purpose.  The report on the interviews, Public Engagement in a Civic Mission, is on the web here. 

But the communitarian focus on relationship and its cluster of related themes like community, service, connectedness and the like is also apolitical. Under a garment of affect (the “warm and fuzzy” associations evoked in the Academe cover), it hides the diverse, often contending interests, conflicts and power dynamics which are always present in colleges and universities and their complex relationships with communities and publics. 

In particular, to go back to “positivism,” the idea of connection does not surface the implicit devaluation of multiple forms of knowledge – cultural, local, experiential, spiritual – which a half century of detachment has worked.

I would propose that a focus on “civic agency politics” as the next stage of our movement. It emphasizes connected knowing in the service of collective empowerment.

In the face of multiplying global crises, from economic collapse to global warming and sectarian and ideological conflict, many signs of civic agency are also appearing.  Civic agency involves collective empowerment -- skills, confidence, and outlook for people to become shapers of their lives and communities and agents of change, in open environments without tightly predetermined outcomes. Civic agency is central to the effort by a group of scholars to define an emergent “civic field,” who organize the annual Institute of Civic Studies at Tufts.

Civic agency is built through what we call public work, based on a concept of the citizen as a co-creator of a democratic way of life, a view that emphasizes politics’ productive as well as participatory, deliberative, and distributive aspects.  Civic agency is an alternative to conventional ideological politics, on the one hand, and community service and volunteerism, on the other.


But we are also caught in a corrosive knowledge war that presents a fierce obstacle to a politics of civic agency.  On the one side are detached and technocratic champions of the singular authority of scientific and disciplinary knowledge—what might be called the cult of the expert. Those of us in research universities are all too familiar with the posture of “the best and the brightest,” bringing solutions to those viewed as ignorant, passive, needy, and pitiable.  As we have come to better understand the inner workings of higher education, we have found that the expert cult is often a cover for deep insecurities – research faculty members are generally better understood as isolated and trapped scholars than as arrogant know-it-all experts. But the consequences of detachment are nonetheless dramatic. As Josiah Ober observes in Democracy and Knowledge, classical Athens had many practices and methods of aggregating expert and amateur knowledge. In contrast, “Contemporary practice often treats free citizens as passive subjects by discounting the value of what they know…Willful ignorance is practiced by the parties of the right and left alike.” An Athenian brought by time machine to the present would see the cloistered expert approach to problem solving and policy making as “both worse for democracy and less likely to benefit the community.”

The cult of the expert has many effects. Professionals have narrowed identities from “civic” to “disciplinary” – no longer are most teachers or clergy or businessmen and women schooled to think of themselves as building the civic life of a place through their work. Dominant models of knowledge-making undercut the moral and civic authority of forms of knowledge that are not academic – wisdom passed down by cultural elders, spiritual insight, local and craft knowledge, the common sense of a community about raising children.  As they do so, they also undermine the confidence, standing, and authority of everyday citizens without degrees and formally credentialed expertise. As former Occidental College president Ted Mitchell has observed, one percent of Americans or less produce the knowledge that “counts.” 



Institutions of many kinds – from schools to nonprofits, businesses to congregations, government agencies to universities – have lost community roots. In consequence, “institutions” have come to be conceived as abstract, bureaucratic, largely impervious to culture change, defined by rules, regulations, structures, and procedures, not as human creations that can in turn be re-created. They are also, often, profoundly disempowering.


But everyday citizens are not innocents in the knowledge war. An anti-intellectual “know-nothing” culture of victimhood and grievance has spread, especially dysfunctional for those in poverty or social isolation. Know-nothing politics disparages academic knowledge, science, and professional practices in the name of community and personal experience. This has been long developing. It was at the heart of “the Reagan Revolution,” pervaded the Bush presidency, and more recently has animated a number of candidates on the conservative side, from Sarah Palin to Rick Perry and Rick Santorum. The appeal of their messages reflects an overlooked divide in America – in recent elections, differences in education levels were a far more salient factor in how people voted than income levels. 


We have to get beyond expert cults and aggrieved communities if we want to develop civic agency, the capacities of people and communities to solve problems and to generate cultures that sustain such agency. This means a return to what I would call the civic and populist spirit and politics of great movements in our past, like the cooperative, union, community, and cultural organizing of the 1930s. These mingled multiple kinds of learning and knowledge with a broader agenda of democratization.   In those years, many colleges and universities were called “democracy colleges,” for their deep rootedness and relationship in community cultures, and their strong emphasis on educating students and professionals generally as citizens.


Civic agency politics is reviving today in a number of efforts and initiatives which promote and develop civic agency in learning, knowledge production, and relations with communities. Here is this argument with three sets of pictures:


The first, with a quote from Saul Alinsky, a founding figure in community organizing, has pictures from the on-line exhibit “New Deal for the Arts,” originally in the National Archives. The pictures convey the agency of working people and professionals, alike, in the movements of the Great Depression.


 “The world is deluged with panaceas, formulas, proposed laws, machineries, ways out, and myriads of solutions. It is significant and tragic that almost every one of these proposed plans and alleged solutions deals with the structure of society, but none concerns the substance—the people. This, despite the eternal truth of the democratic faith that the solution always lies with the people.” Saul Alinsky, 1946





A more overtly political work, Lest We Forget recalls the plight of landless farmers in the American South and the organizing efforts of the Southern Tenant Farmers' Union. Marked Tree is a small Arkansas town that was the site of anti-union violence. Ben Shahn traveled through Arkansas in 1935 while working as a photographer for the Resettlement Administration. .



The second picture is of one of the two sets of statues of ordinary citizens (“Bread Line”) in the Roosevelt Memorial, with an accompanying quote from a famous 1989 speech by Donna Shalala, “Mandate for a New Century,” which called for reconnection with the society, renewal of the public service mission of higher education, led by progressives (she touts every cause of the left in her speech) who form a “technocratic elite.” Shalala’s is the default politics of knowledge of today. It produces cultural imagery of a passive citizenry waiting to be rescued.

“The ideal [is] a disinterested technocratic elite…society’s best and brightest in service to its most needy [dedicated to] delivering the miracles of social science [on society’s problems] just as doctors cured juvenile rickets in the past.” Donna Shalala,  “Mandate for a New Century”         1989



The third is of Fridley Middle School, where a group of “EBD” (Emotionally, Behaviorally Disabled) middle school students, coached by their two teachers and special education graduate students from Augsburg College, have experienced what we call an “empowerment pedagogy,” Public Achievement.” An empowering pedagogy contrasts with the dominant behavioralist pedagogy. The middle school students organized two projects of significance, one to bring solar power to their school, the other on homelessness. Both involved interaction with politicians, businesses, academics and others. As Cheryl McClellan puts it below, they transformed themselves and the school culture in the process.

 “Students labeled Emotional Behavioral Disability (EBD)  are tucked out of sight in basement classrooms or in the furthest corners of schools.  They may go to school, but they are not part of the school culture.  Public Achievement offered a way to change this, and it did. Leaders and visionaries have emerged from this group of students labeled as “behavior problems.” The students have announced their presence to the school community and redefined what it means to be in an EBD special education program.” Cheryl McClellan, Public Achievement coach



Fridley Middle School can be understood as a seedbed for the revitalization of ‘democracy colleges.” More broadly, is is a site for an emerging freedom movement in the 21st century. It points toward a politics which breaks us free of the constraints, labels, stigmatizations, and mystifications of technocratic societies. When connected knowing is understood as a politics, not simply a set of relational practices, it is central to this movement.

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Lina Dostilio, Graduate Student Network Chair, IARSLCE Board


Lina Dostilio

Director Academic Community Engagement, Duquesne University
Graduate Student Network Chairperson, IARSLCE Board


As a graduate student, I am grateful for the ways in which the Association nurtures novice researchers and helps them to connect their interests to a deepening body of community engagement research.  The theme of Connected Knowing reflects a spirit within the Association that has influenced my own research and development as a connected practitioner scholar.

My current work  (a dissertation) is concerned with community-university partnerships that are democratically oriented. It draws upon and connects research in education, organizational and institutional development, social psychology, and social coalition building. As I considered multiple disciplinary bodies, epistemologies, and ways of knowing, I was moved beyond my primary disciplinary training. I found it necessary to connect my strong educational research foundation to other bodies of work and as a result, encountered the loneliness that can accompany developing scholarship outside of a traditional trajectory.  This is a loneliness that is not all that unfamiliar to those of us who consider ourselves to be what John Saltmarsh describes as the next generation of engaged scholars. Many of us have a few supportive faculty within our respective graduate programs who understand service-learning and community engagement. Some of us are fortunate to have faculty who have contributed to these literatures. From my conversations with the Association’s graduate students, we most often find ourselves needing the support and guidance of scholars outside of our campus homes and beyond our disciplinary fields.

As the next generation of engaged thinkers, we intuitively seek to build connected knowing; we embrace identities that shatter a traditional faculty role, taking on mantels as practitioner scholars, scholar activists, and even critics to engagement research; and we weave our intellectual traditions with those of other cultures and epistemologies.  The Association provides a home to this spirit of intertwining and intervening work, and this year’s conference theme most appropriately brings this spirit to life.

Our Graduate Student Network (GSN) provides opportunities for me to connect my thinking to other incubators of thought. I have served as an Editorial Fellow, an experience that positioned me to critically review many innovative research projects. I am mentored and mentor others. I found a group of critical thought partners who were all interested in the construction of reciprocity and we established a thinking and writing group to which our divergent interests contribute strong analysis. Finally, I have the opportunity to use the upcoming conference as a vehicle to connect my studies to other cutting edge work and to develop a plan for how I might continue a research trajectory. While my trajectory may have once felt outside of the norm, it now feels supported and connected, giving me a sense that I am doing important work with other engaged thinkers. I feel connected. My work is connected. And, I look forward to connecting to your work at this year’s conference.

Wednesday, March 7, 2012

Julie Hatcher, IUPUI


Julie A. Hatcher, Associate Professor, Philanthropic Studies
Senior Scholar, Center for Service and Learning
Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis

As an educator in higher education, I am keenly interested in creating “connected knowing” experiences for college students.  Through my own experience and understanding of good teaching and learning practice, I value learning experiences that challenge students to connect their learning to prior knowledge, connect their learning across multiple disciplines, and connect their learning to future action within communities through their personal and professional lives.  It is this latter dimension of connected knowing that I find of most importance.  I often challenge students to consider how what they are learning can impact their future action as citizens and professionals.  I endorse John Dewey’s concept of “social intelligence”; knowledge is gained in relationship with others and knowledge is to be used to improve social conditions.  Developing civic-minded graduates, who will in turn become civic-minded professionals is a vital role for colleges and universities to assume in democratic society. 

Yet how this type of “connected knowing” develops civic-mindedness is unclear.  Certainly, research indicates that prior experiences in family networks, schools, volunteer activities, faith-based organizations, and international travel all contribute to civic-mindedness among graduates and professionals.  And we know that both informal and formal mentoring relationships are very important within learning environments and professional settings.  Yet there is an added variable that is of significance, indeed is of statistical significance, to developing civic learning outcomes, and that is “dialogue across difference”.

I have become more attune to “dialogue across difference” through collaborative research projects in the last couple of years with both the Bonner Foundation and the Project on Civic Reflection.  Led by the ongoing research and evaluation work by Cheryl Keen, I was invited to assist in the design of the 20th Anniversary Study of Bonner Alumni, a national study of graduates of the 4-year, service-based scholarship program funded by the Bonner Foundation.  At the IARSLCE conference in 2010, we presented preliminary findings.  After our session, Dan Richard, University of North Florida, approached us with an interesting question.  He was interested in teaching a service learning course in a graduate statistics class and wondered if he could use the data set generated from the Bonner research.  As a result, Dan and his graduate students embarked upon a semester project to unpack the relationship between a number of variables and the concept “civic-minded professional”.  Of all of the variables, “dialogue across difference with others who are different than me” carried the most weight in terms of its relationship to civic-mindedness.

This concept of “dialogue across difference” is a fundamental principle used by the Project on Civic Reflection (soon to be the Center for Civic Reflection).  Facilitators are trained to lead a small group of participants in structured and thoughtful reflection about a short thought-provoking poem, story, or essay.  The goal is to clarify personal values and commitment and to build civic capacity and community through dialogue.  Comments are shared, ideas are pursued, and insight is gained.  Participants have included college students in 25 states, including 10 Campus Compact states, AmeriCorps members in 17 states, and civic leaders across the country, including Illinois, Florida, Washington (DC), Montana, and New Hampshire. It is a powerful tool that can be readily adapted within service learning classes and co-curricular activities.  Preliminary research indicates a number of benefits derived from civic reflection.

I look forward to the upcoming conference as an opportunity for such dialogue.  Without a doubt, it is rigorous research that will generate and test theory, increase understanding of service learning and civic engagement, and inform good practice and public policy.  Yet it is dialogue, especially with others who are different than me, that will challenge my thinking, deepen my understanding, and ultimately sustain my motivation and commitment to the research and the work that I do.  The IARSLCE conference will offer numerous opportunities for such dialogue.  Whether it is over coffee with new colleagues, during the graduate student reception, or as part of the question and answer time allotted within each session, dialogue, by design, is a fundamental aspect of the learning environment at this conference.  We welcome your participation!

Shelley Billig, RMC Research


Shelley Billig, Vice President, RMC Research Corporation

Connected Knowing as a theme for the 12th IARSLCE couldn’t come at a better time.  There has been a strong push in both the PK-12 and higher education world to conduct useful research, to translate that research into practice guidance and tools, and to disseminate the information as quickly and as widely as possible.  The IARSLCE can be a wonderful catalyst for research to practice, and this theme can help us to organize our efforts and bring at least some of them to scale.

Our review of the studies on research to practice in education shows that there are six major challenges to be overcome: 

1.     Knowledge issues, such as having few conclusive results, poor technical quality, and lack of relevance or utility for practice;
2.     Accessibility issues, such as weak information channels among researchers, practitioners, and policymakers and limited skills among practitioners to understand and interpret research findings;
3.     Professional culture problems such as researchers and practitioners having different languages and priorities, overreliance on professional wisdom or consensus, and the highly contextualized knowledge created from the research community;
4.     Careless or inappropriate use of the research from the practitioner side and overclaiming results on the research side;  
5.     Systems issues, such as having a fragmented research enterprise, few credible models of using research to shape educational policies, no mechanisms for using the research efficiently to redesign educational policies or practices; and
6.     Of course, limited funding. 

The way to begin to overcome these challenges is to develop research diffusion models, establish boundary-crossing practices across disciplines, and engage in developing knowledge communities and systematic dissemination vehicles and mechanisms.  The IARSLCE does this – we have multiple opportunities to share research, develop common research agendas, provide valuable expert feedback on studies, and publish our results. The IARSLCE is the only research community that serves K-12 service-learning purposes and one of the few that serves higher education in an interdisciplinary approach to service-learning and community engagement research.  We are the place to convene and share our work to serve the research to practice needs of the field.

For these and many other reasons (including meeting the nicest researchers in the world), I urge you to consider submitting your research papers, be they around findings, theory, or methodology, for presentation at this conference.  If accepted (or not), you should come to the conference to join in on the effort to advance both research and practice in our field.  At the least, you will gain knowledge.  In addition, you will gain access to a network of researchers who are passionately dedicated to service-learning and community engagement and to furthering research to practice to improve the educational experience of all students. 


Saturday, March 3, 2012

Andrew Furco, UMN


Andrew Furco is the Associate Vice President for Public Engagement and Associate Professor at the University of Minnesota

"Connected Knowing" is the perfect theme title for 2012 International Research Conference on Service-Learning and Community Engagement. Both explicitly and implicitly, the term, “connected knowing”, characterizes the essence of service-learning and community engagement research. In so many ways, it embodies what the annual research conference has sought to accomplish over its twelve-year history. 

Since its inception in 2001, the annual conference has sought to bring together producers and consumers of research from across varied and disparate academic disciplines to connect their particular perspectives of service-learning and community engagement to build a more clear and more well-articulated field of study and practice. It is through connected knowing across the disciplines that the field of community engagement research has been built.

The annual conference encourages connected knowing by showcasing new findings from brand new, cutting edge research studies and then linking this new knowledge with the previous research in the field.  Every year, through the conference presentations, the research base for service-learning and community engagement is further strengthened, helping to build the current robust body of knowledge for service-learning and community engagement.

Because of the multi-disciplinary nature of service-learning and community engagement, the research in the field draws from a broad range of theories and relies on various methods and paradigms of inquiry, ranging from positivistic experiments to more interpretative and critical inquiry.  The annual research conference intentionally seeks to connect these different ways of knowing in ways that enlighten us about the strengths and limitations of each paradigm and method.

The annual conference was established with the specific intention of linking the service-learning and community engagement research knowledge that is produced within higher education contexts with the knowledge that is produced within K-12 and other educational contexts.  By connecting research knowledge from across the educational spectrum, the body of research on community engagement has been strengthened in innumerable ways. For example, this connection has helped identify similarities and differences in how older and younger students experience service-learning and community engagement.  It has also helped bring to the fore the universal aspects of service-learning that are important, regardless of participating students’ educational levels.

As an international conference, the annual conference supports connected knowing across national border and cultural boundaries. With research sessions facilitated by participants from dozens of countries, the conference offers space to explore simultaneously national and global trends in the study and practice of service-learning and community engagement. This work helps us understand more fully the nuanced differences in how service-learning and community engagement is practiced across national borders. After eleven years, the conference remains an important venue for connecting (across national borders) the latest research on service-learning and community engagement.

In many regards, connected knowing is a mainstay of the conference. Each year, the conference connects individual researchers who are interested in advancing the rigor and value of service-learning and community engagement research, but who often do not have within their work setting a community of engagement researchers with whom to collaborate and share their work.  The peer relationships that are fostered through the conference sessions and discussions have engendered a strong, tight knit community of scholars who ultimately rely on each other for support, critique, and encouragement.